There’s no shortage of best-selling bedding on the market. Two top contenders in the comforter category are Brooklinen’s All-Season Down Comforter and Buffy’s Cloud Comforter. Both are beloved by thousands of shoppers for year-round use—so how do you decide between the two? I brought them home to find out.
Here, see how these styles stacked up against each other in a head-to-head—er, sleep-to-sleep—competition. Full disclosure: I’ve been a fan of Buffy’s OG Cloud Comforter for the past eight years, so I have significantly more experience with this bestseller. That said, I tried the latest Cloud model (complete with a few minor updates) during my recent several-night experiment. My husband, who participated and tends to run hot, also shared his thoughts. We opted to use both styles sans duvet covers, though if you prefer an extra layer between you and your comforter, both do have loops in each corner to accommodate them.
Overview of Brooklinen All-Season Down Comforter
It’s important to note that Brooklinen’s Down Comforter is available in three warmth levels: Lightweight, All-Season, and Ultra-Warm. We chose the versatile All-Season style since it seemed most comparable to the Cloud. It’s made with ethically-sourced and produced down and has a classic baffle box construction that helps keep the down fill in place. Meanwhile, its outer shell is composed of smooth sateen cotton.
Fabric: 100% cotton sateen | Filling: 100% Hutterite down | Sizes: Twin/twin XL, full/queen, king/California king | Colors: White
Overview of Buffy Cloud Comforter
The Cloud is one of two best-selling comforters from Buffy that’s designed to work well for hot sleepers and those with sensitive skin. Instead of down, the fill is polyester made from recycled plastic bottles. The comforter’s rounded stitching pattern deviates from traditional baffle box constructions, though I found it works well to keep the fill in place. Additionally, its outer shell is crafted with Tencel lyocell, a soft, breathable, and responsibly-sourced fiber derived from wood pulp. As a bonus, the Cloud comes in a range of stylish colors, so you can easily display it without a cover if you desire.
Fabric: Sateen weave lyocell | Filling: Recycled plastic fill made from water bottles | Sizes: Twin/twin XL, full/queen, king/California king | Colors: White, Slate Blue, Bone Grey, and 8 others
What We Considered
Overall Comfort
Winner: Brooklinen
Both comforters were undeniably comfortable, but Brooklinen’s version had a slight edge for me. While Buffy’s option feels silkier to the touch, I couldn’t get over how plush and airy the Brooklinen All-Season is. It enveloped me like a warm hug without making me overheat. Meanwhile, the Cloud’s polyester fill is more compact, making this comforter feel more like a lightly weighted blanket.
Temperature Regulation
Winner: Tie
The Cloud is known for its breathable, cooling properties—and it definitely lived up to the hype—but the Brooklinen comforter had unexpectedly temperature regulating powers, too. The down comforter managed to keep us both warm without making us feel sweaty or uncomfortable.
Maintenance + Care
Winner: Buffy
As someone with germaphobic tendencies, I’m drawn to anything that’s machine-washable, which is why the Cloud ultimately takes the cake here. It also washed so well after going through a delicate cycle, and it looked and felt exactly the same as it did during the unboxing.
One thing I will note: While you’re only supposed to spot or dry clean Brooklinen’s Down Comforter, I did take the risk of machine-washing it. I ran it on a cold, gentle cycle and was surprised to see how well it held up and maintained its plushness. (Though keep in mind I have yet to see if the results will be the same after multiple washings.)
Price
Winner: Buffy
Brooklinen’s All-Season Down Comforter is nearly twice as much as Buffy’s vegan, down-alternative option, so if you’re concerned about cost, the Cloud is your best bet. Prices start at $299 for the Twin XL Brooklinen style and $145 for the same size Cloud comforter.
The Final Verdict
It’s almost impossible to choose a favorite. My husband and I were surprised by how much we loved Brooklinen’s lightweight-yet-fluffy version, and we agreed that it was our preferred style—especially in this cooler transition period between winter and spring. That said, the Cloud is perfect for those who want a less plush and more cooling effect, since it’s dense but also exceptionally temperature regulating—not to mention, more budget-friendly and lower maintenance. I can definitely see us switching to the Cloud as temperatures rise in the spring and summer months.
Blake Bakkila has been writing about everything from pop culture to lifestyle products for more than eight years. Her work has appeared on GoodHousekeeping.com, WhattoExpect.com, Health.com, and in the print and digital versions of Real Simple and People.
